 |
Please consider a small donation to help me keep this site running.
 |
|
| Recent Topics |
» Blujay Gone Mad
by sciencefare on Wed Jan 07, 2009 5:04 pm
» Rate my new hair care product website
by sciencefare on Wed Jan 07, 2009 5:03 pm
» Hello Everyone - New Here - Ex-Powerseller
by George78 on Wed Jan 07, 2009 4:52 pm
» US Bank Fraud on my home mortgage they ripped me off HELP!
by gooddealsbooks on Wed Jan 07, 2009 4:51 pm
» Need some assistance
by northstar01 on Wed Jan 07, 2009 4:50 pm
» Cant get ionCube running
by massder on Wed Jan 07, 2009 4:48 pm
» For FUN..Anyone up for a game of word association ??
by jimboyposting on Wed Jan 07, 2009 4:35 pm
» eBay Alternatives Pick up Steam in 2008 Thanks to Google
by Lady*Belle on Wed Jan 07, 2009 4:12 pm
» Ex-eBay CEO Whitman to run for California governor
by Protomodels on Wed Jan 07, 2009 3:59 pm
» Sellers/Shoppers, What Do You like-dislike About Ecrater?
by cjalaska on Wed Jan 07, 2009 3:48 pm
|
|
|
 |
| Author |
Message |
Confused Total posts: 202
|
On a scale of 1 - 10 it scores a 5. Ebay scores an 8 and walmart has a 7. |
|
|
|
No rating |
|
 |
vermonter53 Location: Vt. Where Else?? Total posts: 206
|
purple_reading_giraffe wrote ( View Post): › I second both sides of this argument. OLA has a long history of promising improvements that do not materialize in the time frame given. My solution to that is to suggest that people choose or do not choose to use OLA based on its current features, not any anticipated ones.
While it is true that paying up-front a year's fee to obtain a store and a bulklister seems unreasonably greedy to me, and that I think the verified buyer program also feels unnecessarily grasping, there are those who may prefer a one time payment with unlimited listing capabilities. This format also frees OLA from wanting to worry about how final sales are made because they already have their money, so sellers and buyers are free to make whatever arrangements they wish and sellers are free to use the site to link to items or stores that are hosted on other sites, a rarity in the alternatives who mostly have adopted ebay's restrictive TOS in this area.
OLA also has a google page rank of 5 which is better than many other alternative sites (mostly smaller ones) listed at auctionnews.org's sitewatch.
My main problem is the way in which discussions of OLA seem to degenerate so quickly at PSU. I don't feel that to call those people who have a positive experience to share at any particular venue fools, and kool-aid drinkers, and cheerleaders is productive at all. I also don't think that to imply that those who are dissatisfied with their experience using any particular venue are in some way incompetent or lazy is productive either. I am more impressed by those that discuss the issues, their opinions and impressions, and forgo the drama. There are a few who like OLA and spring to its defense, as there are a few who appear so unhappy with their experience that they can let no positive comment go unanswered.
I am aware that there is a long history for OLA and a LOT of information available here and elsewhere for folks to research before trying the site. However, due to the nature of forums and the internet, fresh information is more readily heeded. So both sides need to feel free to have their say without the argument becoming personal almost every single time. And to my observation, it is almost always the people who feel that OLA is NOT a good choice that are the first ones to call names and impugn the character and motives of those who report that they are pleased with OLA. This is not to say that I think those with negatives to share should not state those negative points, but I would hope they would strive to do so without inflaming the discussion with personal attacks.
I see both positives and negatives with OLA as an alternative venue. I see that some seem to do well there and are happy to have found the place. I see that the site itself is not able to provide exceptional or even very good exposure of its sellers' items.
I see that a Google Base Feed was promised and has apparently been made available for sellers to use themselves, though I am only barely informed on this subject at this time. However, I believe that individual submission by stores to googlebase may be how ebay does it (or maybe it's an option), and seems to give a small preference in Google Product Search returns over site-wide submissions, and is how BISI does it. However, I don't think that providing a CSV is going to meet the needs of a lot of sellers, though there are some OLA sellers who are listed in Google Products right now, so seem to be using this tool.
I have heard that the bulklister is difficult to use and many sellers end up doing cut-and-paste of listings to move them, even those with long experience at OLA. I have also seen some say they like listing at OLA, though I have also seen much higher praise for the formats of some other sites.
I have nothing to report on the current condition of search or shopping on the site as I have been generally inactive in all the alt stuff since June. However, I have observed that OLA seems to be showing up better in Google web search than was the case earlier this year, and I did observe changes occurring to how Google perceived page titles and such in May or June, so I can confirm that work of some sort has been done in Google search visibility.
My personal impression of OLA is that promises should be taken with a grain of salt and not be figured in to anyone's business plan. The fact that the verified buyer program has not been changed one iota despite numerous well-reasoned protests gives me the strong impression that a source of income is more important than the users' experiences. I cannot tell why some do well and some do so very badly, but almost any alt will draw little to no buyer traffic on its own, most seems to come from buyers finding an item they are looking for with some other means of searching, be that search engines, shopping sites, or social bookmarking, so OLA is not alone in requiring self-promotion. I also get the impression that OLA tends to consistently "miss the boat" for whatever reason.
I am aware that OLA talks on the front page about the total number of items available. While most out-of-the-box sites only mention listings, there are several "independent" sites that I have come across (SportLots.com and AtomicAvenue.com to mention a couple I visited just yesterday) talk about total items. I also will note, yet again for those new to this furor, that anytime one browses a category or puts in a search at OLA, the number of LISTINGS is prominently displayed at the top of that page. As far as I've seen, the number of items only appears on the home page and is, IMO, a fair marketing tactic. And I note that this is one of the most common complaints about OLA seen on these boards, many times explained and answered.
My bottom-line advice to any seller considering which alts to try is that if you decide to try OLA you do so at $8 a month to find out how the back-end works for you, and you consider if the items you sell, or related ones, seem to do well there and if there is room for your items in that market. Do not expect that OLA, just because it is larger in terms of listings, will automatically attract buyers en-masse and be another eBay. It won't. But then again, neither will iOffer or Craigslist or eCrater.
P.S. I am personally glad that MetzyMom has found some success with her excellent soaps at OLA. With such a good product, though, I suspect she could find success in many venues. I am personally sorry that others of the Feb and May ebay exoduses did not find that OLA meets their needs, and that they felt they relied on promised improvements that failed to materialize in the ways and timeframe that they expected. And I suggest to you folks that Bonanzle and AtomicMall, fledgling sites though they are, may be well worth looking at to expand your online presence. |
Thanks!
A voice based on reason, not emotion amongst chaos
Pros, cons and opinions....NO attacks....
It's great, keep it up! it might help  |
|
_________________ Click here to Check out MY OLA HOUSE, TAMISHAS TREASURES
Ban Ethanol, Please use 100% REAL GAS |
|
No rating |
|
 |
Howmanyhorses Total posts: 32
|
|
No rating |
|
 |
anniesplace Total posts: 98
|
In reply to post 62
It is much easier to stay emotionally detached when you haven't laid down your hard earn money for a site that promises everything and delivers nothing.
Many of the people who have posted their experiences with OLA have been ripped off to the tune of $196.00. I guess they feel a little emotional.
My question is how do you stay so loyal to a site that takes your money, promises upgrades, new improved site and delivers nothing but new window dressing. How long are you supposed to wait? You are paying a minimum of $8.00 a month. You can list at many sites for free! Please do not give me the old story that OLA doesn't promise to promote your site, that is up to you the hard working individual, just be patient the google feeds will be put in place soon, and on and on. Please, just answer this, why do you stay loyal to this man Fain? |
|
|
|
No rating |
|
 |
AtomicMall.com Location: Yakima, WA Total posts: 386
|
METZYMOM wrote ( View Post): › Mike, what I was referring to was that there are rules of conduct at AM too, whereas OLA gets slammed for theirs. Every site has ROC. I used you as an example, that's all. |
It was a bad example. The discussion was about OLA management deleting posts and closing down boards. You then chimed in and claimed I had done "EXACTLY the same thing" at Atomic Mall. That statement is blatantly untrue.
For the record, the only posts I've deleted on my board were from an unregistered spammer who was flooding the forums with advertisements in Chinese writing. I've never deleted a user's post, and I've certainly never deleted entire sections of the forum. The incident you refer to was merely me adding my $.02 to a thread which I felt had gone off-track. Nothing more or less. No one was banned. No posts were deleted. No feelings were hurt. It was in no way related or even similar to what occurred on your board, so your characterization of it being "exactly the same thing" is absurd, and I think you know that.
In the future, I would greatly appreciate it if you would restrict your public comments about me or my company to statements of fact only.
Thank you,
Mike Shannon |
|
_________________ Import your Auctions and chat with Buyers & Sellers in Realtime!
www.atomicmall.com
atomicmall.proboards50.com
 |
|
No rating |
|
 |
arcanesanctuary Total posts: 324
|
Quote: › Ban Ethanol, Please use 100% REAL GAS |
Give me an order of baked beans and I'll give you all the real gas you need  . |
|
|
|
No rating |
|
 |
METZYMOM Total posts: 750
|
No problem Mike. I take back everything I said. I'll call my friend tomorrow and explain that I was wrong. I'll edit the post so that your site isn't mentioned, and I'll do the same at OLA where I did the Atta Boy.
I was just so sure I read your Chat TOS (posted on April 9th) correctly and that it did say that "Any post may be deleted, modified or moved at any time for any reason, as deemed appropriate by the board moderator(s)." I was also sure that the original post (post #10 in a thread titled: The OLA Cafe Has Been Temporarily Suspended)that was emailed to me had you cautioning your users that you wanted things to be kept "upbeat and forward-looking" and to let "bygones be bygones". It looked to me like you had basically set down similar rules as to those OLA is now enforcing and were asking for peace as so many OLA members have done and continue to do. It was honestly meant as an example, not a slam on your site.
My mistake if I misunderstood and wasn't factual when relating it back. I won't mention your site again. |
|
_________________
|
|
No rating |
|
 |
AtomicMall.com Location: Yakima, WA Total posts: 386
|
METZYMOM wrote ( View Post): › I was just so sure I read your Chat TOS (posted on April 9th) correctly and that it did say that "Any post may be deleted, modified or moved at any time for any reason, as deemed appropriate by the board moderator(s)." |
Of course I reserve that right. Every board administrator in the world reserves that right. If someone starts posting on my board tomorrow about the wonderful benefits of joining the Aryan nation, or lists someone's private personal information without their consent, I'll probably exercise that right. That's a no-brainer.
But to take a snippet from our TOS about an action I have the *right* to perform, and say that it's " exactly the same thing" as a separate incident in which certain actions WERE performed, is a complete fabrication on your part. Put simply: you publicly stated that I did something I did not do. Now you're attempting to defend those actions by showing how I *might* do it. That's quite a stretch.
If OLA wants to shut down areas of their forums, that's their business. I have no beef with them, but don't lazily accuse me of actions I have not taken. That's sneaky and underhanded and I have no time for those who use such tactics.
Quote: › you cautioning your users that you wanted things to be kept "upbeat and forward-looking" and to let "bygones be bygones". |
Yes I said that, although I think with the word "caution" could be replaced by the word "encourage". Still, a post encouraging my users not to dwell on the negativity of past events is not " exactly the same thing" as deleting multiple posts, removing forums, and restricting access.
Is it?
Quote: › I won't mention your site again. |
I don't mind you mentioning my site. I would just prefer that you tell the truth when doing so. |
|
_________________ Import your Auctions and chat with Buyers & Sellers in Realtime!
www.atomicmall.com
atomicmall.proboards50.com
 |
|
No rating |
|
 |
METZYMOM Total posts: 750
|
Again, the example was only that site admins everywhere have pretty much the same disclaimer... the only difference is that OLA used theirs after trying unsuccessfully to keep the same peace you asked your users for...
That was the intent of, and certainly the meaning of my statement. It is regrettable that it was taken the way it was, that it could taken so far off of what was intended and meant.
It won't happen again. |
|
_________________
|
|
No rating |
|
 |
FashionHairShop Total posts: 59
|
|
No rating |
|
 |
jistincase Total posts: 75
|
And if you would have read all of it too you would have seen that it was at the request of the OP that it be done so to foster a more positive environment and forget all the failings of ola. Mr. Z did so only at that request and begrudgingly so. We have nothing to complain about there because things are working great, people are coming in all the time and are buyer to seller ratio is about 4:1. I can tell you without even looking it up it isn't even close over there. We as a group of former sellers from there decided that we were not going to keep dragging ola over there to hash over and cast a shadow over the great things happening at AM.
I am sure that if the day comes that we need to discuss serious problems at AM that it will be done in a respectful and business like manner because they have delivered on what they have said and have never tried to hide anything from the members. It's one thing to talk a good talk like ola but AM is walking the walk. |
|
|
|
No rating |
|
 |
dlrane Total posts: 1574
|
|
No rating |
|
 |
sciencefare Location: Port Dickinson, NY USA Total posts: 1526
|
FashionHairShop wrote ( View Post): › can anyone advise a good place to sell goods other then ebay |
Hello FashionHairShop!
Yes, I can recommend the Atomic Mall to you. Many sellers are finding that quickly after setting up shop and listing their items, they are having sales.
Since listing your items is free of fees, you can list what you want, risk free, with no time constraints. Your items stay listed at no cost to you until they sell.
Hope this helps a bit.  |
|
_________________ It is nice to be important. It is more important to be nice.
 |
|
No rating |
|
 |
2BOYSandTOYS Location: Kansas Total posts: 9397
|
Mike - very well stated and very logical.
There often seems to be an attempt by some to compare one site to another as well as on site's community to another. When facts are used, it's easy to discern the differences and similarities. However, when suppositions, assumptions and 'feelings' are used, it turns into a dysfunctional mess (most of the time).
I believe you've clarified well, and hopefully the thread can return to the topic/title as posted.
To support the OP and the intent, the biggest factual reason the OLA will not work for most online sellers coming from eBaY is no visibility in search engines.
For comparison purposes, eBaY submits buy-now items and store items to Google Products, Yahoo Shopping and a few other engines for shoppers.
OLA submits to no known shopping engines.
All other alternatives beyond eBaY submit to Google Products (and a few more) at no charge to sellers.
2 (maybe more, but don't think so based on my research) submit to Google Products, Oodle, and a broad base of shopping search engines - they are AtomicMall and Kaboodle.
For any sellers looking for one/two alternatives to test-drive, do your research. Different sites work for different folks. Some cost upfront, others do not. Some have forums, others do not. I could go on and on and on - do your research!!! |
|
_________________ Erin
2BOYSandTOYS - Plunderhere Store
2BOYSandTOYS - AtomicMall Store
2BOYSandTOYS - eCrater Store
AtomicMall - Sell with the BEST! - Squidoo Lens - Stop by and Add your store! |
|
No rating |
|
 |
OutWest4Less Total posts: 577
|
Ebay has created a Monster.
That will be their downfall.
You can't allow Buyers to critique Sellers in opinionated areas.
4 DSR areas.
Based on a 5 star system and coaching by Ebay to the buyer that a 4 is good across the board. That's a positive. Ebay looks at it as a NEG. Just like they looked at Neutrals as a NEG.
Ebay has stated that if your DSR's fall below 4.3, you will suspended. Now, here is another key issue. Suspended!! There is no Un- Suspension Policy within Ebay. Once you are suspended, you are GONE!!
Now. Is there anything higher than getting a 4.0 GPA in College>?
Are we now going into the rarefied arena that 4.0 is not good enough?
And if this is the case, then why try as a solid performer that only can perform at a 3.8 GPA average.
Are these very smart and industrious people relegated to be Pizza Delivery People? Because all the 3.8 GPA jobs are sent overseas due to lowering Company costs like providing Helath Benefits, Workman's Comp and Social Security and approved and validated by the current 8 year administration.
Keep it up, Mr Bush and if your proptege becomes Prez and keep increasing the size of the Fed GoV to offset and skew the Un-Employment in this country. Go Ahead and keep sending jobs overseas to avoid the basics that this country was built on. Go Ahead and allow more and more Golden Parachute Artists to fly away. Go ahead and figure out ways to increase the membership Billionaire Club. Go Ahead and increase the membership Millionaire Club. |
|
_________________
 |
|
No rating |
|
 |
|
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum You cannot attach files in this forum You can download files in this forum
|
|  |